Clay Aiken and Ruben Studdard give American Idol fans a blast form the past in their new Broadway show, and PEOPLE has the exclusive first-look Dave Quinn is a Senior Editor for PEOPLE.

Kelly Clarkson Accidentally Forgets Clay Aiken Didn’t Win His American Idol Season: 'So Sorry, Ruben' Why Clay Aiken Says Parenting Son Parker, 16, Is 'Happy and ...