Let’s take a trip down memory lane… Dave Meltzer didn’t give any WWE matches a 5-star (or better) rating in the 1980s, though Ricky “The Dragon” Steamboat and “Macho Man” Randy ...

It's a day that ends in y, so somewhere, someone is complaining about "five-star matches," or the man who popularized such a rating, Dave Meltzer. Even if the Wrestling Observer Newsletter head ...

And get a five-star rating from legendary wrestling reporter Dave Meltzer. However, despite always having favorable thoughts about the quality of AEW matches, he actually questioned the approach ...

The topic of Dave Meltzer and his star rating system was ... and that in the grand scheme of things five star matches don't put someone's bills or put food on someone's table.

Dave Meltzer has awarded Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn's Unsanctioned Match at WWE Elimination Chamber 2025 ***** in his latest star ratings ... match at Bad Blood 2024 (5 October).